MangaBullet: red asks, "What keeps a club alive/active?"

What keeps a club alive/active?


the members (fandom/forum/comments)  49%
the contests/ activities  29%
the person/moderators running the club  11%
the type of club it is (original/anime/fanclub)  8%
other  1%
168 votes
) : i was browsing fanclubs to join cuz i was bored.

it's kinda of saddening to see clubs with no members or just one or two members.

But then again most of those clubs are repeats off more popular clubs.

When you create a club, do you know how to keep it active? How to get more members? I think most people aren't thinking much and waste their one free club. I've seen some pretty weird ones out there too!
yukisukinomoto
5 Jul 08
3:29 PM
yukisukinomoto  is a clairvoyant medium who has nightmares she enjoys
(smiley)... ahahaha. Members. I don't mean spammers but definitely people who are active in talking about their interests in the club. (smiley)... at least I hope so. haha.... T_T
atmosblue
5 Jul 08
3:31 PM
atmosblue  
Agreed.
busiu
6 Jul 08
12:30 PM
busiu  Is yurmom who, by the power of the moon, will punish you!
Agreeeed. (smiley)
Zefster
5 Jul 08
3:38 PM
Zefster  doesn't want to go back to school. ;__;
Haha, I know what you mean. (smiley) I made a club for Tegaki E, and now I regret it because there's really no fun activities or contests I can do for it. (smiley)

I've been seeing some pretty weird/stupid clubs lately too... xD
red
6 Jul 08
11:41 AM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
i'm sure you can start some |D and you have this awesome presence * U * !!
tegakie master!! OTZ!! (smiley)(smiley)
bakakimi
5 Jul 08
3:38 PM
bakakimi  is on a short hiatus but will reply to comments.
It doesn't matter if the club has lots of contests or activitees. They're not going to go well unless the club has members that are willing to participate. C:
yun
5 Jul 08
3:55 PM
yun  Is an uke who is in denial
MEMBERS. Since they can really push at the moderators and everything else into gear with their spazzy contributions. xDD AND THEY'RE HUGE IN NUMBERS. (smiley)< (smiley)(smiley)

Haha I'm a quiet lurker member-- unless when I'm not. Hah |D
red
5 Jul 08
4:20 PM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
ohoho you're not that quiet in our rp are you, yunababy? ; D !! *smooch* (smiley)
yun
5 Jul 08
5:10 PM
yun  Is an uke who is in denial
SHHH D//:

LOLOMG ahhh I bet your inbox is like all EWWWYELLOW. I'll stop now. xDD;;; (smiley)
red
5 Jul 08
5:46 PM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
LOL I LOVE YELLOW ; D let's make orange baby (smiley)
(smiley)(smiley)(smiley)
yun
5 Jul 08
7:48 PM
yun  Is an uke who is in denial
How do you like your orange? ;D ahaha HONESTLY. (smiley)(smiley)(smiley)
red
5 Jul 08
8:44 PM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
warm and loving ; D (smiley)(smiley)(smiley) LOLOL
Little-Neco
5 Jul 08
4:07 PM
Little-Neco  Is a Jpop singer who caught 'em all
It's the members. Unfortunately, when most people hit the join button they're hoping for more attention when they do so. I mean, they end up on the front page for a bit, and anything art- wise they do ends up on the front page as well. So if you see in- active clubs, it's because of an extreme lack of interest among the members.
red
5 Jul 08
4:19 PM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
ah well said~ well hmm there really isn't a front page scenario like that of DA here xD i mean how much attention are you getting? lolol
i just lurk in the forums |D!
Little-Neco
6 Jul 08
12:48 AM
Little-Neco  Is a Jpop singer who caught 'em all
Sadly, most of the clubs I'm a part of don't even have captains, so nothing happens in them...
(Well, when you first join a club your icon sits on the list until people bump you off... and if clubs don't get a lot of "fanart" for them then someone's art could be occupying that space for a while. xP)
red
6 Jul 08
11:18 AM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
ah really? like is it run by clubot? I usually try to assign presidents to those seeing as yes, no one is able to post blogs and important stuff xD maybe you can show me some of them?
LOLOL yeah (smiley) that sucks so bad JFDKLs i wish you can view other fanarts instead of seeing just the recent arts
Little-Neco
7 Jul 08
11:31 AM
Little-Neco  Is a Jpop singer who caught 'em all
Actually, I commented on the clubot page because other people were asking to be president of clubs that way. I noticed that the Case Closed, Disgaea, and the Legend of Zelda clubs are run by the Clubot. If you could, actually, could I be the president of at least the Disgaea fanclub? All of the ones I listed are the Official ones, I believe.
red
7 Jul 08
1:02 PM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
Ah seems good : ) I wish you best of luck with the club (smiley)
Sush
5 Jul 08
4:20 PM
Sush  I R BABOON Big STAR of Cartoon
I'd say members because I think I at least try with my Minekura club by posting news and stuff and I found a few fans and asked them to join, and I try discussions but I guess I fail. But I don't regret making it because I love her so much *u* but I guess it depends how popular the fandom is. OTL
Ah dunno, I think duplicate clubs are annoying (smiley)
Azuness
5 Jul 08
4:25 PM
Azuness  Is a dominant seme who tops Kappa and Karyu ♥
OTL -scurries off to update blog-
Innocent-raiN
5 Jul 08
4:25 PM
Innocent-raiN  Is an angel who was spirited away
I think ultimately its the members that make the club. If people aren't being active or trying to start conversations with one another or asking questions on forums, etc. then it doesn't really go anywhere (smiley)

I hate it when there's a club with over 100 people and nobody's doing anything
Despiness
5 Jul 08
5:12 PM
Despiness  Is a fulf who likes to hide in your pants.
The members totally keep a club alive >w<;
Without them, it's just a total flop (smiley)
nonononi
5 Jul 08
5:29 PM
nonononi  is a creep who loves shota
I have yet to type up any blogs, or start any contests for my club. But people still join, and I think it's only really to support, and have a place to put their fanart. (Because it's a pairing club (smiley))
red
6 Jul 08
11:37 AM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
ah 5927 right? |D (smiley)
nonononi
6 Jul 08
11:54 AM
nonononi  is a creep who loves shota
Why, of course (smiley)
LydiaRayne
5 Jul 08
5:32 PM
LydiaRayne  Is an undocumented lolcat who doesn't know how to do that backwards 'b'
Members. Big surprise. But also the mods. If a club doesn't blog I forget to check the forums. (I'm a bad mod) But it's also a pain to have to click the clubs to see what's going on in the forums. And I find members start a lot of fun forums but if there's no blogging I forget to check the forums.

Also the point of the club. I'm not very into the fandom clubs but I love the random ones. It's a lot of fun talking about non-anime/manga/whatever but being able to throw in anime references, or just be geeky. I love how this site attracts the anime/manga/video games and ext but we all talk about everything. Wow. Off topic.

It's the members and fun mods.
red
6 Jul 08
11:36 AM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
xD ahaha orly? i check clubs almost everyday to see if anything's stirring up lol but that's because I have like no life OTL *digs a hole*
ah but lately the blogs are all messed up no? ; n ; !!

LOL (smiley) very true, dear |D! lol i find those general ones about loving anime so pointless ahhh~ sad to waste your free club ne?
LydiaRayne
6 Jul 08
9:44 PM
LydiaRayne  Is an undocumented lolcat who doesn't know how to do that backwards 'b'
I'm the worse mod in existence. I'm not the pushy 'pay attention to my club' type so if no one does anything...well neither do I. And clubbot can't really do anything. Maybe he'll evolve in a thousand years like in the movies. Plus I hate hate hate when there's a clubbot and a non clubbot club for the same thing. Ahem. Maybe I shouldn't be saying that. Yup.

The fandom ones have a major flaw. An anime/manga/video game is only popular for so long. Sure I love Bleach right now, but in a few months who knows. And the popular anime right now is of course going to have more members then the anime that is truly a classic.

Ya the blogs are messed up but I noticed a lot of clubs are putting their names in the updates so at least I know what club to go to. Oh well. Eddz can enjoy his vacation.

I want no life!! But people wont leave me alone! Trade me *pleading eyes* pretty pretty please. You can have all my stuff!! And and my 'collections' (smiley)
akizumi
5 Jul 08
5:39 PM
akizumi  Is a ninja who faps like the wind
I really don't know, Mr. Red.
/useless :B
red
6 Jul 08
11:28 AM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
: O really now? *pets you* (smiley)
akizumi
7 Jul 08
6:54 AM
akizumi  Is a ninja who faps like the wind
^^(smiley)
-Catherine-
5 Jul 08
6:02 PM
-Catherine-  Is a purple Gamer girl who likes...stuff n things.
Yes I do run a club. ouO

and sometimes it seems like nothing moves until I post something.
and then the members buzz around a bit..
calm down
and die.

and then I have to post something again. ouO;;

so iduno. in MY case, it seems the mods/admins.
red
6 Jul 08
11:27 AM
red  is so excited for Mangabullet's new staff members!
Ooh which club? * U * !!
ahaha yeah it usually happens like that ; n ; ! ahaha that's why I assign some really lively people as moderators xD and things just go nuts in the forums ohoho xD
-Catherine-
6 Jul 08
2:14 PM
-Catherine-  Is a purple Gamer girl who likes...stuff n things.
The Guild of Awesome Lamers =o

unfortunately my mods are either lazy peices of fat or mostly inactive. ouO;;

so it's pretty much just me,
the 4 or 5 people who actually comment,
and 40 other people who do nothing. :c
paper
5 Jul 08
6:06 PM
paper  Is a Peeping Tom who will kick one's ass and take one's name
What's the point of having a club if members aren't going to participate? A club is there to gather people of the same interest. The members keep the club alive, and it tends to be the members that ultimately mutate the club to involve contests and such, to fit their needs.
Or.. that's my opinion anyway OTL
noxnoctis
5 Jul 08
6:54 PM
noxnoctis  Is a seme who likes buttsecks very much
I'd imagine that having a club with devoted members is a good foundation.
You need good club leaders and event organizers that can run things efficiently, and effectively, as well as keep up with the needs of the members.
Club events, contests, get-togethers, and good relationships between members is really what keeps a club alive.
bernoully
5 Jul 08
7:17 PM
bernoully  is a satellite weapons platform who ion-cannons emo people for the lulz